Optical laryngoscopes- a new angle on intubation
Anthony Padley
Westmead Hospital, Sydney, Australia
Introduction
The past few years have seen a proliferation of optical
laryngoscopes that do not require alignment of the oral, pharyngeal
and laryngeal axes. If the patient can open their mouth 2.5-3 cm
these instruments will usually provide a grade 1 view of the larynx
when direct laryngoscopy fails. These devices therefore have a
profound relevance to the management of the anticipated and
unanticipated difficult airway and all anaesthetists should be
adept with one or two types.
Types of Optical Laryngoscopes
The four most important types on the Australian market are the
GlideScope, CTrach, Pentax-AWS and the Airtraq.
The GlideScope was developed in the US in 2002 and looks like a
conventional laryngoscope but has a camera in the blade tip. A
video cable carries the camera image to a separate portable screen.
Although easy to use and providing an excellent image of the larynx
there is no guide for the ET tube. Several injuries to the palate,
palatopharyngeal arch and other airway structures have resulted
from trying to blindly maneuver the ET tube and introducer into
view.1,2
The CTrach was introduced in 2006 to improve upon the Fastrach by
providing a fibre-optic bundle and clip on LCD screen. An advantage
of the CTrach is that it provides an excellent conduit for
ventilation. However the laryngeal view on the overly complex
screen is often poor or absent (in 45% of cases in one study).3
Additionally intubation requires a large number of time-consuming
steps.
The Pentax-AWS (Airway Scope) was developed in Japan and released
in 2006. The handle contains batteries, a light source and a 5.3 cm
LCD screen and is connected to a 12 cm cable with a camera unit at
its distal end. The cable is inserted into a transparent lock-on
blade which has a guide for the ET tube. There is a suction port
but no specific anti-fogging device.4
The Airtraq was developed in Spain and also released in 2006. It is
the only single-use fully self contained optical laryngoscope and
relies on a system of lenses, prisms and mirrors and its own
battery powered light source and anti-fogging device. The image of
the larynx through the large proximal lens is of excellent quality
and panoramic. There is a grooved guide for the ET tube.
Choice of the Airtraq at Westmead Hospital
The Airtraq was chosen for use at Westmead Hospital because it is
very easy and intuitive to use with intubation achievable in under
20 seconds. They are relatively cheap ($90 per unit) compared to
the outlay required for the CTrach and GlideScope ($15,000 each).
Concerns over deterioration over time of complex components such as
LCD screens and cameras are not relevant to the Airtraq.
Experience with the Airtraq
Training in the use of the Airtraq has been provided by 3 senior
anaesthetic consultants supervising intubations of mannequins and
patients for elective surgery. In addition the Airtraq has been
used successfully in the following situations up to the time of
printing (numbers of patients in brackets):
- Patients with a grade 3 direct laryngoscopy at a previous anaesthetic (3)
- Patients who were not predicted to have a difficult airway that could not be intubated despite BURP and use of a Teflon bougie (4).
- A patient with a suspected cervical spine injury.
- An awake intubation in a patient who had failed a previous intubation attempt at another hospital.
- A patient with severe facial trauma.
In all the above cases except 5) a grade 1 laryngeal view was
obtained. In the facial trauma patient the senior anaesthetist who
used the device was able to visualize bubbles emerging from an area
where he thought the larynx should be and successfully intubated
the patient.
Conclusion:
Optical laryngoscopes such as the Airtraq have an emerging role in
the management of anticipated and unanticipated difficult airway
management. As long as the patient can open their mouth 2.5-3 cm
these devices have a high probability of providing an indirect view
of the larynx and enabling intubation. All anaesthetists should be
familiar with at least one or two of these devices as they
represent a significant advance in anaesthetic safety.
References:
- Chin KJ, Arango MF, Paez AF, Turkstra TP. Palatal injury associated with the GlideScope®. Anaesth and Intensive Care 2007;35:449-50.
- Cooper RM. Complications associated with the use of the GlideScope® video laryngoscope. Can J Anesth 2007;54:54-57.
- Liu EH, Goy RWL, Chen FG. The LMA-CTrach a new laryngeal mask airway for endotracheal intubation under vision: evaluation of 100 patients. Br J Anaesth 2006;96:396-400.
- Asai T, Enomoto Y, Shimizu K, Shingu K, Okuda Y. The Pentax-AWS Video-Laryngoscope: The first experience in one hundred patients. Anesth Analg 2007;106:257-259.